Debates continue over the validity of using journal citation reports and impact factors in the ways they are currently used to assess the value of scholarship, determine the best candidates for faculty positions and prioritise researchers for grants and other funding. In the midst of this debate, I was struck by a couple of recent postings on the Scholarly Kitchen blog that focus on what is actually meant by the words ‘citation’ and ‘impact’ in this context (http://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2015/07/16/when-do-citations-reflect-impact/ and http://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2015/08/04/if-we-don’t-know-what-citations-mean-what-does-it-mean-when-we-count-them/).
There are certainly significant differences in the nature and purpose of scholarly citations, and what constitutes impact is at times difficult to define. Certainly, one piece of scholarly research and writing influences another when the first provides ‘the intellectual foundation, the inspiration, or vital information for the argument’ of the second, as the author suggests, but scholarly impact can be much more subtle, even negative, and still constitute a viable intellectual influence. Even the sort of citation the author of the postings questions as valid impact – when ‘the primary source is faked or misdated’ or ‘the quantitative work is off’ – has made an impact, if in no other way than forcing the scholar citing the work to point out its errors. Often the mistakes of others help to clarify the thinking of the author who catches the errors, and checking the facts or confirming one’s own results when assessing the situation can be a useful exercise as well.
I have no problem, then, with considering a citation a signifier of influence. Where the essential problem lies to my mind is in rewarding the author of a cited article for his or her deception or poor scholarship as the current system does, and that is only one example of the complications associated with citations. Without a means to assess the precise nature of citations before counting them as career credit, it is virtually impossible to distribute that credit appropriately. As the author of the posts asks, ‘if we don’t really know what individual citations mean, why do we think we can draw important meaning from their aggregation?’ As interesting as the information we gain from such quantitative methods of tracking citations and impact may be, it is incomplete without detailed analysis of what it actually means. Such methods are also prey to biases and unethical practices much as qualitative assessment methods are, and they are not comprehensive, with citations to obscure or primary sources often neglected.
The ability to track citations is a wonderful resource, but only if what we do with it is fair and reasonable. It is simply poor scholarship to draw conclusions without fully understanding the data obtained, and it is sad to think that quality scholarship that may be of great value to many readers might be considered insignificant as a result.
Why Our Editing and Proofreading Services?
At proofreading services we pride ourselves on the exceptionally dedicated team of academic and scientific professionals who provide our English editing and proofreading services. Our editors and proofreaders are highly educated native speakers of English who have undergone rigorous training in expert editing practices, and their fields of study and specialisation range so widely that we are able to help our clients improve and polish research manuscripts of all kinds for successful publication. Many members of our research paper editing and proofreading team focus on journal editing, manuscript editing, scientific manuscript editing, academic proofreading, academic editing, dissertation proofreading services, professional proofreading, thesis editing services and scientific proofreading, assisting authors with articles that will be submitted to scientific and academic journals by ensuring that the formatting and references in their manuscripts conform to the relevant guidelines with precision and by correcting grammar, punctuation, spelling and typing errors to enable the clear and accurate communication of original research that acquisitions editors expect in publishable papers.
Our scientific editing, medical editing, bioscience editing, life science editing, environmental science editing, pharmaceutical science editing, physical science editing, agricultural science editing, LaTeX paper editing, social science editing, political science editing, engineering paper editing, psychology editing, research paper editing, manuscript editing, humanities editing, journal article editing, biomedical science editing, planetary science editing, plant science editing, material science editing, veterinary science editing, behavioural science editing and neurosurgery editing services for authors of scientific papers and reports are especially popular, but we also excel at book editing and have the experience and expertise to proofread and edit books and papers of all kinds across every scholarly discipline. Some of our carefully trained editors and proofreaders work exclusively on PhD thesis editing, master’s dissertation proofreading, bachelor’s dissertation proofreading, thesis editing, dissertation editing, thesis proofreading and dissertation proofreading, applying their education and instructional skills in providing thesis editing and dissertation proofreading services that help advanced students to improve the formatting and language of their theses and dissertations and thereby increase their chances of degree success. Whether you are preparing a conference or class presentation, putting the final touches to a professional report for colleagues or tackling the challenging task of editing any kind of academic or scientific document for publication, a qualified member of our outstanding proofreading and editing team will be delighted to provide proofreading and editing services and boost your confidence in your written work.
If you are in the process of preparing an article for an academic or scientific journal, or planning one for the near future, you may well be interested in a new book, Guide to Journal Publication, which is available on our Tips and Advice on Publishing Research in Journals website.
We also offer the following services:
Pharmaceutical Science Editing
Social Sciences Editing Services
Bachelor’s Dissertation Editing
Dissertation Proofreading Services
editing and proofreading services
proof-reading-service.com review
academic proofreading services
proofreading and editing services
www.proof-reading-service.com review
Research Paper Writing Blog 